Simisoccerfan
PREMIER
It's a busy and expensive weekend in Vegas with the NCAA basketball, too. That said, I think if you're assuming the all the best players are on ECNL and DA teams, I think that's a mistake. We're surrounded by 3 of them and probably 1/3 of those rosters would not displace any of our existing players at tryouts. Maybe if both players showed up as "new", there'd be a different outcome, but the talent level isn't enough to bump an incumbent player. The separation isn't there. Too many reasons NOT to play DA and I guess, with the exception of SoCal, there are probably several regions where ECNL isn't a viable option for some. That said, Stanford, Pepperdine, MIT, Columbia, San Diego... all calls I would certainly return.
I guess the real telling thing will be how well your players get recruited vs those DA and ECNL teams. I don't doubt that your team has players just as good but those leagues get way more college coach exposure. For those that want to play at the next level that is the true benefit of playing in those leagues. My dd's team had 18 players on the team, 13 seniors and 5 juniors. 11 of the seniors played D1 year last year and two played D2. All 5 of the juniors are committed D1 for this fall. Everyone on substantial scholarships. 1/2 of their second team committed to college too (D1 to NAIA). The big clubs with DA and ECNL are recruiting machines.